Appraisal

Last reviewed · June 2026

Appraisal. A written valuation of a diamond — usually for insurance purposes — stating a replacement value at retail. An appraisal is not what a buyer will pay; resale offers typically come in at 25–50% of an insurance appraisal.

Insurance appraisals are deliberately high. They reflect what it would cost to replace the diamond from a retail jeweler — including the retailer's markup of 100–200% over wholesale.

If your appraisal says $8,000, a resale offer in the $3,000–$4,000 range is normal market behavior, not a lowball.

Go deeper

Related terms

← Back to the full glossary A–Z